Carmina Burana: Get orff Carl Orff
January 22nd, 2009Carmina Burana - by all accounts a rather splendid production. I should have known something was wrong when I entered the O2 foyer to find burger wrappers spread around on the floor and sickly smell of fast food permeating the air. Yes, the dome has been there nigh on a decade and I stepped foot inside it for the first time last weekend. Well, I was busy up until now. My reckoning was that being held in the O2 this would be a fairly democratic production, and one that wouldn’t require me to read the twenty four poems that the musical is based upon. I was at more or less a total loss as to what was happening for the entire show.
There was some fairly obvious heaven and hell imagery, but that was a given. The arena is so large and the figures on the stage so miniscule as to make it hard to even follow a character let alone work out who they were meant to be.
The production is (mercifully) short at 1 hour 10 mins. Nevertheless, 10 minutes was eaten up by watching a long procession of torch wielding monks walk slowly through the audience and onto the stage. The suspense and tension was notable by it’s absence as the audience continued their pre-show banter, all be it whispered. That in itself created more of an atmosphere.
The choreography and dancing was laughably bad. At first I took this to be high camp, but came to realise that it was nothing more than ineptness as the show wore on. Stumbling attempts by the devil to lift his heavenly counterpart did nothing to alleviate this feeling. And why were they wearing stilts when they were evidently useless at walking on them. At times they looked akin to newly fledged rugby playing transvestites trying out stiletto heels for the first time.
Stage hands clearly seen rolling Fortune’s Wheel into place further helped to shatter any illusion, as did the blasts of a fire extinguisher which erupted from the darkness at the end of a particularly firework strewn scene. The fireworks were as disappointing as some ‘indoor fireworks’ I was foolishly tempted to part money for as a young lad. I felt similarly cheated this time, though the price was somewhat higher.
Flags fell off poles threatening to trip up dancers, giant forks drooped, nudity did not prevail and confusion abounded, as people who’d seen enough began to take their leave at around the half way mark. I wish I’d joined them in the bar, but optimism kept me seat bound. Although perhaps not optimism, but the kind of urge that makes you look at a crash scene on the opposite side of the motorway.
I’d understood that the poems were by and large lewd, but the the perfect opportunity for a ‘puppetry of the penis’ type of comic display was completely missed during a scene when two lovers (barely) cavorted behind an illuminated curtain. Even Terry and June would have made a more convincing go of it.
The sound system was entirely inappropriate to the size of the venue and to the nature of the music. I like to feel my bones and bowels resonate to rousing classical music. The system hardly made the hairs in my ears move, and was woolly and flabby.
I could go on, but I think you get the picture. I don’t think I’ll bother with the O2 again, let alone Carmina Burana.
(Apologies to Carl Orff, none of the theatrical nightmare was really his fault of course)















